BSA Decisions Ngā Whakatau a te Mana Whanonga Kaipāho

All BSA's decisions on complaints 1990-present
All Decisions
Television New Zealand Ltd and TV3 Network Services Ltd - 1999-041, 1999-042

3 News and Nightline. When interviewed by TV3 news, Christchurch gunman's flatmate alleged he had been paid to talk exclusively to another news organisation; this was followed by shot of a vehicle marked "One Network News". TV3 news was advised by 9.15pm that the flatmate had not been paid but the item on Nightline at 10.30pm repeated the allegation. Upheld (accuracy, fairness). Order (broadcast of statement).

Robertson and Television New Zealand Ltd - 1999-043, 1999-044

One Network News. Item referred to the millennium celebrations being organised for the City of Gisborne, and stated they were to take place on 1 January 2000. At the conclusion of the 6.00pm news programme, TV One displayed a digital clock counting down the time to the start of the year 2000. Not upheld (accuracy standard not not relevant: not the Authority's task to decide the issue of factual accuracy in relation to the issue).

Butchart and Television New Zealand Ltd - 1999-045

Holmes. Item referred to a contest "to conceive the first child of the new millennium"; in describing the contest, the presenter talked of "this first child of 2000". Not upheld (accuracy: not the Authority's task to decide on the issue of whether it is factually accurate to imply that the new millennium begins on 1 January 2000).

Gillies and TV3 Network Services Ltd - 1999-046

3 News. Item concerned the arrest of members of the Headhunter gang. Complaint that footage showed gang members giving the camera, and, he believed, the viewers, "the fingers". Not upheld (good taste and decency).

Diocese of Dunedin, Kirkpatrick, Somers-Edgar, Rothel and Sim and TV3 Network Services Ltd - 1999-033–040

20/20: "Sex, Lies and Videotape" and 3 News. Interim Decision. TV3 sought an assurance from the Authority that it would cease taking any further action on the complaints until either the complainants had advised that they did not intend to pursue remedies in defamation, or a decision had been made by the High Court. The Authority raised the matter with the four complainants and the Diocese, and was advised that none had commenced proceedings at that stage. They reserved their rights concerning any defamation proceedings. The Authority therefore intended to proceed with determining the complaints as planned, as it was not satisfied there was any reason to postpone the process. –

Jones and The Radio Network Ltd - 1999-027

Newstalk ZB breakfast programme: "World City". Host read a dramatised story which purported to tell of the relationship between two lovers. Script contained a number of implied sexual references. Not upheld (good taste and decency, children's interests, violence).

Mauger and Radio New Zealand Ltd - 1999-028

Nine to Noon. Author was interviewed and discussed "her fast fire novels about sex and love and cellulite." Not upheld (good taste and decency).

Whitmore and Television New Zealand Ltd - 1999-029

Breakfast. The word "Poms" was used in reference to the English cricket team which was touring Australia. Not upheld (discrimination and denigration).

Zarifeh, on behalf of the Wellington Palestine Group, and Radio New Zealand Ltd - 1999-030

Morning Report. Item consisted of an abbreviated headline which referred to an upcoming item; complaint that land mentioned was not in Israel, but was illegally occupied by Israel. Not upheld (accuracy: any ambiguity was resolved by the full item which was broadcast subsequently).

R and The Radio Network Ltd - 1999-031

Newstalk ZB morning programme. In the context of a discussion about driving habits, the host described how that morning he was passed at speed by a car which then crossed all three lanes to exit from the motorway; he identified the car by its personalised license plate. The car's owner complained that this was an invasion of his privacy. Not upheld (privacy).

1 ... 339 340 341 ... 446