BSA Decisions Ngā whakatau a Te Mana Whanonga Kaipāho

All BSA's decisions on complaints 1990-present

All Decisions
Dunphy and Television New Zealand Ltd - 1994-019

One Network News. Item contained shots from the courtroom proceedings of an appeal, which included showing a number of files. Complaint that the full name of one of the children was clearly visible on the folder spines as was the surname of a second. Upheld (privacy). No order: action taken sufficient.

P and TV3 Network Services Ltd - 1994-021

20/20: "Hear No Evil – Speak No Evil". Item about father's incest with his five daughters. Complainant, who was one of the two daughters not inteviewed, had not wanted the programme made and disputed the eldest sister's account of events. Upheld (balance). Upheld: majority (privacy). Declined to determine (law and order, accuracy). Subsumed (fairness). No order.

Voters' Voice Binding Referendum Inc and Television New Zealand Ltd - 1994-016

One Network News. Item on launch of the New Zealand First political party reported that Voters' Voice was closely linked to the right-wing League of Rights and had been kept outside the gates. Upheld (accuracy, one aspect). Subsumed (fairness). Not upheld (good taste and decency, balance, discrimination and denigration, responsible programming). No order.

Comalco (NZ) Ltd and Television New Zealand Ltd - 1994-014

Frontline. Item focused on electricity pricing arrangements and raised questions about the rates charged to domestic and large commercial consumers. Upheld (fairness). Not upheld (balance, responsible programming). Declined to determine (accuracy). No order was made.

AKO Ltd and Television New Zealand Ltd - 1994-015

Radio Wha Waho. Light-entertainment series set in a Maori radio station. Complaint that the first four programmes misused the Maori language and invited viewers to laugh at rather than with the Maori characters. Not upheld (good taste and decency, fairness, discrimination and denigration).