BSA Pānui - Free speech's impact on diverse communities

Number 149
Kia ora koutou
 
Today we’ve released new research showing the harms experienced by Māori, Pacific Peoples, Asian and Muslim communities due to encounters with media and online content.

Research carried out for the BSA by AK Research & Consultingopen_in_new with these communities suggests Aotearoa has yet to find the right balance between freedom of expression and potential harm.

Over three-quarters of those surveyed feel exposure to offensive, discriminatory or controversial views is a problem – and large numbers say they are avoiding TV and radio as a result of misinformation and inappropriate content.

Social media is the platform where those surveyed most often encounter offensive material, and is considered the most harmful. This is concerning given the lack of effective regulation in this area.

But many believe conveying such content on mainstream media can contribute to legitimising harmful views. Talkback radio and social media are seen as offering a degree of anonymity that can encourage people to voice more extreme (and less informed) views. [Click on infographic to see full size]

Regulatory implications

While the most common response to encountering harmful content is to talk to family or friends, respondents said there were situations where they would go through official channels.

Personal impacts, including threats of potential violence or harm to their families, are key motivators for making a complaint to the likes of a broadcaster, the BSA, or the Human Rights Commission.

Our findings raise serious broader issues to be tackled in much-needed reform of content regulation – including the need for a regime that effectively addresses social media. Future reforms should also consider the cumulative impact of harmful content and seek to deal with systemic issues.

Trust in media

With other research pointing to a steady fall in the public’s trust in media generally, our survey also offers useful insights into what’s impeding trust and engagement with media among our diverse communities.

This is important, as a free, independent and trusted media is a cornerstone of a well-functioning democracy, and the ability of groups to participate and benefit from healthy democratic processes and institutions.

An industry-led national wānanga last year hosted by Stuff, bringing news media and community leaders together to find ways to improve trust in news through better representation, was a positive step – but our research findings suggest there’s still a way to go.

Our team is available to present the findings in more detail to newsrooms, community groups and other stakeholders. If you’re interested in booking a session, please get in touch.
 
You can see our media release in several languages, and read the research report, on the BSA website:

   Media Release: Half of diverse audiences avoid broadcasts due to harmful contentopen_in_new
   Research: Freedom of expression and harms impacting diverse communitiesopen_in_new


Ngā mihi mahana
Stacey Wood
Chief Executive
FEATURED DECISIONS


Communities Against Alcohol Harm and NZME Radio Ltd - 2024-026 (2 September 2024) open_in_new

The Authority has upheld a complaint that action taken by NZME in response to a breach of the promotion of illegal or antisocial behaviour standard during a segment of Fletch, Vaughan and Hayley on ZM was insufficient. The Authority agreed that the item, which discussed searching for the cheapest alcohol with the highest alcohol by volume (ABV), amounted to alcohol promotion that was socially irresponsible. While the broadcaster upheld the complaint, removed the relevant segment from their online podcast and counselled the content directors and hosts of ZM on their obligations around alcohol promotion, the Authority found this was insufficient to remedy the harm caused by the broadcast – noting, in particular, there had not yet been any public acknowledgement of the breach for the audience.

Upheld: Promotion of Illegal or Antisocial Behaviour (Action Taken)

Order: Section 13(1)(a) – broadcast statement 



Milina and Discovery NZ Ltd - 2024-029 (16 July 2024) open_in_new

The Authority has upheld a complaint that promos for Quiet on Set: The Dark Side of Kids TV, Paper Dolls and The Playboy Murders broadcast during family movie Scoob! breached the offensive and disturbing content and children’s interests standards, and that action taken by the broadcaster in response to the complaint was insufficient. The Authority found that, viewed cumulatively, the promos went beyond expectations of the host programme and its PG-VL classification, and scheduling them during Scoob! meant the broadcaster did not enable child viewers to be protected from potentially unsuitable content. The Authority did not make any orders, however, finding publication of the decision was sufficient to publicly notify and remedy the breach and to provide guidance to the broadcaster and broadcasters generally.

Upheld: Offensive and Disturbing Content, Children’s Interests (Action Taken)

No Order

LATEST DECISIONS

NEWS AND RESEARCH

New Zealand International


Subscribe to the BSA Pānui newsletteropen_in_new