BSA Pānui - June 2020

Number 101
MESSAGE FROM THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE

Kia ora koutou
 
The BSA team is now back in the office and there has been no time for pause. After a reduction in complaints during lockdown, they are increasing again, with 24 formal complaints received in the last month (compared to 10 in the same period last year). We received a sharp increase of enquiries in April and May with the team dealing with 243 inquiries, compared with 173 in the same period last year. As we reach the end of our financial year, we are getting ready to send out our last batch of decisions which takes our decision number to 111, compared with 90 last year.

The media plays an important role in creating awareness about issues, and in enabling voices to be heard. This has been highlighted in the recent global coverage of racial inequality. Reporting on these issues requires care and broadcasting standards of fairness, accuracy, balance, and the discrimination and denigration standard provide guidance to broadcasters as they bring these stories to our community.  A number of our decisions issued in the last month set out below, touch on these standards and provide guidance to broadcasters.

In the lead up to the 2020 Election and Referenda, we are focused on ensuring that broadcasters and the public are aware of the standards for election programmes (promotional clips by candidates and parties on radio and TV in the election period) and aware that complaints about such content can be made. Broadcasting standards for election programmes recognise the importance of free political speech in the lead up to a general election, where political parties and candidates are seeking to influence voters, and audiences are seeking information to enable them to make informed voting decisions. The broadcasting standards are designed to define where the exercise of free political speech may be limited. Information about the Election Programmes Code is on our website hereopen_in_new.
 
We are working with ASA, the Electoral Commission and the NZ Media Council who also have a role in responding to complaints and concerns by the public about Election/Referenda content. Details about the different roles we play are hereopen_in_new.
 
We hope you enjoy this Pānui and that you, your friends and whānau are keeping safe.

Ngā mihi
Belinda 

OVER THE LAST MONTH

  • Together with the Electoral Commission, ASA and NZMC we presented a Webinar for media on the requirements for election and referenda advertising, election programmes and other election-related material in broadcast, print and digital media.
  • We have updated our website with guidance on the election programme requirements and provided details of the fast-track process we will operate for election content complaints. For more information see hereopen_in_new. 
  • The fieldwork for our Broadcaster survey and complainants survey was completed this month. Thank you to all those who completed the surveys.
  • The 2020 broadcasting levy process will commence shortly. We acknowledge the challenges facing the sector and we will support broadcasters in this process. Levy returns and questions can be sent to us at: levies@bsa.govt.nz.
FEATURED DECISIONS

FREE-TO-AIR TELEVISION

Brereton & Riches and MediaWorks TV Ltd - 2019-097 (16 June 2020) open_in_new

The Authority has upheld two complaints that a segment on The Project, about an incident where charges against a man who allegedly shot at a drone were dropped, was in breach of the fairness and accuracy standards. The Authority found the segment was unfair to the man and would have misled audiences as it provided an inaccurate account of events through an interview with the drone’s pilot and additional comments from presenters. The drone pilot interviewee was allowed to put forward unchallenged his views on the man, and the broadcaster did not do enough to provide the man with an opportunity to respond to the comments. As the broadcast did not disclose any private information about the man, nor discuss a controversial issue of public importance, the privacy and balance standards were not upheld.

Upheld: Fairness, Accuracy

Not Upheld: Privacy, Balance

No orders

RADIO

Singh and Radio Virsa - 2019-081 (27 May 2020) open_in_new

The Authority upheld a complaint that a segment of Punjabi talkback programme, Dasam Granth Da Sach breached the good taste and decency, violence and law and order standards. During the segment, the host made threatening comments, directed at members of a Sikh sect in response to recent violent incidents in India. The Authority found the comments undermined widely shared community standards, considering their seriousness, specificity and other contextual factors. The Authority also found the comments actively incited violence and promoted disrespect for the law within the specific community of listeners. The Authority recognised the value of the broadcaster’s right to freedom of expression but found the potential for harm justified a restriction of this right.

Upheld: Good Taste and Decency, Violence, Law and Order

Orders: Section 13(1)(a) broadcast statement

LATEST DECISIONS

MEDIA NEWS

New Zealand Abroad

Subscribe to the BSA Pānui newsletteropen_in_new