Kia ora koutou
Issues around gender identity have generated significant public debate and media attention, and some high-profile BSA decisions, in recent times.
Following an influx of complaints about TV and radio coverage of gender identity issues, including about last year’s New Zealand visit by Posie Parker, we commissioned the latest instalment in the BSA’s biennial
‘litmus testing’ surveyopen_in_new to explore community attitudes.
The survey looked at whether BSA decisions relating to these issues under the Discrimination and Denigration, and Fairness broadcasting standards reflect these attitudes and are understood by the public.
It found New Zealanders see significant public interest in airing diverse views on gender identity but are concerned about the potential for community harm.
Views are similar across ages and ethnicities, but levels of concern over potential harm versus the right to freedom of expression differ markedly according to people’s comfort levels with gender diversity.
Malicious intent and the risk of harm to vulnerable gender-diverse communities are top-of-mind for those more comfortable with gender diversity. Those less comfortable prioritise freedom of speech, and perceive a lack of a balanced discourse which is not in the public interest.
Despite the polarisation in people’s perspectives, there appears to be a broad appreciation of the challenge we face and support for the BSA’s decision making.
An average of 91% of survey participants agreed with five BSA decisions that were tested.
This is a pleasing assurance that our decisions reflect community standards and are generally getting the balance right with our fundamental task of balancing freedom of expression against potential harm.
The results show a consensus that respectful sharing of perspectives on TV and radio can be beneficial to society. This must, however, be framed constructively to avoid unintentionally – or intentionally – harming viewers or listeners. People are saying it’s not okay when an opinion is intentionally malicious.
We’ll take the findings into account in future decisions. We’re also making the report available to broadcasters and other stakeholders who may find it useful.
You can see our media release and read the full research on the BSA website:
Media release - New Zealanders weigh public interest and potential harm in gender identity discussionopen_in_newLitmus Testing 2024 – Decisions relating to gender identityopen_in_newNgā mihi nui
Stacey Wood
Chief Executive