BSA Pānui - 20 December 2023

Number 143
Kia ora koutou,

As we enter the final few days before the holiday season, I’d like to take this brief opportunity to thank you all for your work in informing and entertaining audiences and working with us within the co-regulatory broadcasting framework.

Below you can see the BSA's last decisions for the year. Our office will be closed from 5pm on Thursday 21 December and reopens on Monday 8 January.

We wish you and your loved ones a happy, safe and restful Kirihimete and look forward to working with you again in 2024.

Ngā mihi nui
Stacey Wood
Chief Executive
staceyw@bsa.govt.nz

FEATURED DECISIONS

FREE-TO-AIR TV

Alexander and Discovery NZ Ltd - 2023-076 (29 November 2023) open_in_new

An item on Paddy Gower Has Issues investigated the predator control of feral cats, and discussed whether or not feral cats should be included in the Predator Free 2050 strategy. The broadcast included footage of feral cats being trapped and shot, and people carrying, and holding up the carcasses. The Authority did not uphold the complaint the broadcast breached multiple standards, finding relevant footage was clearly signposted by the host, who provided two warnings to viewers about the content. Viewers were therefore given a reasonable opportunity to make a different viewing choice for themselves or children in their care. The footage depicted no undue cruelty or suffering, and while some viewers may have found it unpleasant to watch, the broadcast of hunting and pest control footage is generally acceptable in New Zealand provided it does not depict undue cruelty. Under the balance standard, the Authority found the broadcast sufficiently alerted the audience to the existence of other perspectives. The Authority found the fairness and promotion of illegal or antisocial behaviour standards either were not breached, or did not apply.

Not Upheld: Offensive and Disturbing Content, Children’s Interests, Fairness, Promotion of Illegal or Antisocial Behaviour, and Balance

RADIO

Spring and Radio New Zealand Ltd - 2023-079 (29 November 2023) open_in_new

The Authority has not upheld a complaint that an interview with a woman concerning her removal from an anti-co-governance meeting on Morning Report breached the balance, fairness and accuracy standards. The complainant alleged the broadcaster should have included balancing comment from, or interviewed Julian Batchelor (the speaker at the event concerned). The Authority found the interview did not require balancing comment as it did not ‘discuss’ the issue of co-governance, and did not treat Batchelor unfairly. The woman’s removal alone did not constitute a controversial issue of public importance. The accuracy standard did not apply as the complainant did not allege any statements were misleading.

Not Upheld: Balance, Accuracy, Fairness

LATEST DECISIONS

NEWS AND RESEARCH

Subscribe to the BSA Pānui newsletteropen_in_new