BSA Pānui - May 2020

Number 100
MESSAGE FROM THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE


Kia ora koutou

Our last Pānui was written during the Level 4 Lockdown while broadcasters were working under strict protocols as essential services and the full BSA team was working from home. Now under level 2, we are continuing to work from home, as we prepare for a gradual transition back to our office, and broadcasters are taking stock of the impact that COVID 19 has had on our sector, our community and our economy, while continuing to provide broadcasting services to all of us.  was written during the Level 4 Lockdown while broadcasters were working under strict protocols as essential services and the full BSA team was working from
 
This experience has highlighted the value that standards play in providing an ethical framework that promotes accurate, balanced and fair news reporting, and provides safeguards that keep broadcast audiences safe, particularly our younger generation, from content that may harm them. 
 
In this environment, we have continued to deliver all of our services with some key highlights this month which are summarised in our Over the Last Month section below.  The decisions released are also profiled. Alongside our complaints and oversight work, we have contributed to the work undertaken by the Ministry for Culture and Heritage (MCH) to develop the media support and recovery package. Our focus has been to ensure that the views of all broadcasters, large and small are considered in the support provided.  More details about the support packages are available on MCH's website hereopen_in_new.
 
A key highlight in April was the launch of our campaign to raise awareness about the changes to timebands and classifications on free-to-air television.  These changes are the result of 3 years of hard work and collaboration between the BSA and broadcasters, to adapt our standards system to the modern environment and to enhance important classification and timeband safeguards.  Please check out our new website www.safeviewing.co.nzopen_in_new, where, with some entertaining guidance from How to Dad Jordan Watson you can learn about the changes and pick up some tips to keep kids safe from content that might harm them.
 
Equally important last month, was the release of a guidance note on reporting on terrorism and violent extremism.  This has been prepared reflecting principles applied to reporting during the March 15 Mosque attacks, with valuable input from broadcasters.
 
We are acutely aware of the challenges facing the broadcasting sector and our community at this time.  Working together to emerge from this crisis, resilient and open to new opportunities is key.  For BSA, our attention is now on the 2020 Election, and the role we play in overseeing standards under the Election Programmes Code and working with other organisations such as the Electoral Commission, ASA and Media Council to address concerns that the community may have about election content.
 
We hope you enjoy this Pānui and that you, your friends and whānau are keeping safe.

Ngā mihi
Belinda 

OVER THE LAST MONTH

  • New safeguards for free-to-air television took effect on 1 May 2020 with the changes to timebands and classifications on free-to-air television and promotion of the use of parental locks. Despite the lockdown BSA and broadcasters worked together to launch an extensive awareness raising campaign on TV, radio, print and online media supported by How to Dad, Jordan Watson.  See www.safeviewing.co.nzopen_in_new to find out more about the changes, and tips to keep kids safe from content that might harm them.
  • In April we released our Guidance Note on Reporting on Terrorism, Violent Extremism and Crisis Eventsopen_in_new. The guidance note was prepared in consultation with broadcasters, and captures principles from BSA decisions on complaints about media coverage of the 15 March Mosque attacks.
  • During the lockdown with more eyes and ears on broadcaster content we reminded viewers about the importance of standards in providing a safe environment to enjoy broadcast content. Our guidance on safeguards for children watching television during lockdown is hereopen_in_new.
  • Reminders for Broadcasters: The broadcaster survey closes on 29 May 2020 - we encourage all broadcasters to provide us with their views, by completing the survey. The 2020 levy process will commence shortly and any final 2019 levy returns are due to us. Levy returns and questions can be sent to us at: levies@bsa.govt.nz.
  • This month we say a sad farewell to Legal Advisor (and resident poet) Jordan  Hamel. Jordan joined the BSA in 2017 and has made a valuable contribution to the BSA team. We have been fortunate to have Jordan' s insight and perspective on a range of cases and projects. He has also been our skilled media manager. Jordan is moving to another position within the public sector and leaves with our best wishes and appreciation.
FEATURED DECISIONS

FREE-TO-AIR TELEVISION

Gibson And Television New Zealand Ltd - 2019-117 (7 May 2020)open_in_new

In a 1 News report on the ruling of the UK Supreme Court that Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s decision to suspend Parliament for five weeks was unlawful, a statement was made in the introduction of the item that Boris Johnson had ‘lied to the Queen’. TVNZ upheld the complaint that the statement was inaccurate, apologised to the complainant and held discussions with the news team to ensure that systems were put in place to reduce the risk of inaccurate reporting. The Authority did not uphold a complaint that the action taken by TVNZ was insufficient, finding that the action was appropriate and proportionate to the breach identified.

Not Upheld: Accuracy (Action Taken)

Richards and MediaWorks TV Ltd - 2019-105 (7 April 2020)open_in_new

The Authority did not uphold a complaint about a promo for Love Island Australia, which was available to view online on ThreeNow. The promo depicted the programme host, Sophie Monk and two others as angels sitting in the clouds. The ‘god of love’, a heart-shaped cloud in the sky, called down to Sophie saying, ‘we need more love’. Sophie responded that she had ‘the perfect place for falling in love… a love island’, in response to which the ‘god of love’ asked, ‘and what about hot bods?’ The complainant found the promo offensive as he considered it mocked Christianity and Christian beliefs. Weighing these concerns against the right to freedom of expression, the Authority found the promo’s content would not have unduly offended or distressed the general audience, and it did not reach the high threshold necessary for finding it encouraged the denigration of, or discrimination against, Christians as a section of the community. Therefore, the promo did not cause actual or potential harm at a level which justified limiting the right to freedom of expression.

Not Upheld: Good Taste and Decency, Discrimination and Denigration

RADIO

Woolrych & Glennie And Nzme Radio Ltd - 2019-100 (23 April 2020)open_in_new
The Authority did not uphold two complaints that comments made by Mike Hosking during his Mike’s Minute segment breached the discrimination and denigration and accuracy standards. Discussing two recent immigration policy decisions by the Government, Mr Hosking commented, ‘discrimination is no bad thing’ and, ‘Where do too many of the radicalised nutters come from? That particular part of the planet [Africa and the Middle East]... We don’t want to take the risk of a poor-ish person’s parent arriving – so why a jihadist?’ The Authority acknowledged the complainants’ concerns that Mr Hosking’s choice of language was inflammatory. However, it found that in the context of the item, which carried public interest, the comments complained about were brief and moderated by the remainder of the item. Mr Hosking was expressing his genuinely held opinion on a legitimate issue, rather than being malicious or nasty. Therefore the comments did not reach the high threshold for encouraging discrimination or denigration, and did not warrant limiting the right to freedom of expression. The Authority also found Mr Hosking’s comments were distinguishable as analysis, comment and opinion so the accuracy standard did not apply.

Not Upheld: Discrimination and Denigration, Accuracy

LATEST DECISIONS

MEDIA NEWS

New Zealand Abroad

Subscribe to the BSA Pānui newsletteropen_in_new